| ◄ | Best Ever Non-Winners 2000-2011 | 2011 | Best Non ESC Song by an ESC Artist 2 | ► |
| Pos | Artist | Song | Pts | Player |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1st | Riki Sorsa | "Reggae OK" | 161 | Claire 83 |
| 2nd | Heddy Lester | "De Mallemolen" | 126 | thms |
| 3rd | Nicole & Hugo | "Baby Baby" | 116 | Jaccobabe |
| 4th | Nonstop | "Cosas de Nada" | 112 | gottago |
| 5th | Doce | "Bem Bom" | 108 | weedydiamond |
| 6th | Hot Eyes | "Ka' du se hva' jeg sa'?" | 101 | BigBmad |
| 7th | Bamses Venner | "Tænker altid på dig" | 95 | NightFox_Dancer |
| 8th | E.N.I. | "Probudi Me" | 92 | Pdm1987 |
| 9th | CatCat | "Bye Bye Baby" | 79 | sbrum1984 |
| 10th | Céline Dion | "Ne partez pas sans moi" | 74 | Chickens hit |
| 11th | Bebi Dol | "Brazil" | 70 | marrakech |
| 12th | Olivia Newton-John | "Long Live Love" | 59 | BBAnne |
| 13th | Aivaras | "Happy You" | 55 | pauledin99 |
| 14th | Salomé | "Vivo Cantando" | 53 | Saturn |
| 15th | Linda Wagenmakers | "No Goodbyes" | 52 | Hayum |
| 16th | Gisela | "Casanova" | 51 | Only_You |
| 17th | Aleksandra & Konstantin | "My Galileo" | 48 | youngswede |
| 18th | Renato Micallef | "Singing This Song" | 48 | Drew Peacock |
| 19th | Guildo Horn | "Guildo Hat Euch Lieb" | 44 | Suzy07 |
| 20th | Ich Troje | "Follow My Heart" | 44 | big bro geek |
| 21st | Marion Welter | "Sou Fräi" | 42 | globbits |
| 22nd | Ishtar | "O Julissi" | 39 | Ulfgeirr |
| 23rd | Dschinghis Khan | "Dschinghis Khan" | 38 | Nicky2win87 |
| 24th | Waterloo & Robinson | "My Little World" | 35 | Gill32 |
| 25th | Poogy | "Natati La Khaiai" | 30 | wombatofludham |
| 26th | Verka Serduchka | "Danzing" | 25 | Fudd |
| 27th | Silvia Night | "Congratulations" | 23 | cherubmattd |
| 28th | Barbara Dex | "Lemand als jij" | 19 | Barbara Dex |
| 29th | Anastasia Prikhodko | "Mamo" | 11 | 9ct mould |
| 30th | Daria | "Celebrate" | 3 | ShadyNathan |
| 31st | Dustin the Turkey | "Irlande Douze Pointe" | 2 | JordanC55 |
| 32nd | Natalia Podolskaya | "Nobody Hurt No One" | 1 | steeleuro_wolf |